The appraisal came back under the contract price, and your buyer is looking at you. Before anyone talks about walking away or writing a bigger check, there is a formal step most agents never use: the reconsideration of value (ROV). The rules differ by loan type, and so does the clock. This guide covers what you can actually do on FHA, conventional and VA purchases, and what the rules do not let anyone do.

Key takeaways

  • On FHA and conventional loans, the borrower starts the ROV, and only one borrower-initiated ROV is allowed per appraisal. Your job is to help assemble the evidence.
  • Both FHA and conventional processes cap new evidence at five alternative comparable sales, and the appraiser answers in a revised report.
  • On VA loans there are two windows. Before the report is final, the appraiser must give the requester two business days to send market data (the Tidewater procedure). After the Notice of Value, the Veteran asks VA, not the appraiser.
  • On conventional loans, a request cannot be based only on the fact that the value does not support the loan amount. It has to point to a specific problem.

First, what an ROV is (and is not)

An ROV is a formal request that the appraiser re-assess the report using information that may affect the value conclusion. It is not a negotiation with the appraiser, and the lender cannot pressure the appraiser toward a number. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide says a request to change the opinion of value must be based on material and substantive issues and must not be made solely because the value does not support the proposed loan amount. FHA and Fannie Mae both require the lender’s communications with the appraiser to follow appraiser independence rules, so route everything through your loan officer rather than calling the appraiser yourself.

Federal rules also give the buyer the report itself. Regulation B requires the lender to provide a copy of every appraisal promptly after it is completed, or three business days before closing, whichever is earlier. Get the buyer to send you the full report first. An ROV needs the report in hand.

FHA: up to five comps, one request, no cost to the buyer

HUD Mortgagee Letter 2024-07 added borrower-initiated ROV requirements for FHA case numbers assigned on or after September 2, 2024. Under it:

  • The lender must disclose the ROV process at application and again when the appraisal is delivered, including expected processing times.
  • The buyer may submit up to five alternative comparable sales. Only one borrower-initiated ROV is permitted per appraisal.
  • The comps must be relevant as of the appraisal’s effective date.
  • The appraiser’s response must come in a revised version of the appraisal, even if the value does not change.
  • No costs associated with an ROV may be charged to the borrower, and the ROV must be resolved before closing.

HUD also lists material appraisal deficiencies that can justify a second appraisal ordered by the lender, such as relying on outdated or dissimilar comparable sales when more recent or comparable ones were available. That decision belongs to the underwriter, not to the agent or the buyer.

Conventional: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

Fannie Mae (Selling Guide B4-1.3-12) and Freddie Mac (Guide 5604.4) use nearly the same borrower-initiated ROV rules. The request must include the borrower and property details, the appraisal’s effective date, the appraiser’s name, a description of the unsupported or inaccurate areas, up to five additional comparable properties with their data source (for example an MLS listing number), and an explanation of why the new data supports the request. The lender completes its own appraisal review first. Once the loan closes, a borrower ROV is no longer allowed.

One more conventional rule matters when you renegotiate. Fannie Mae calculates its seller-contribution maximums on the lower of the sales price or the appraised value, not the loan amount. A seller credit that fit the contract price can exceed the cap once the value comes in lower. Our seller concession limits guide has the numbers by program.

VA: two windows, and different rules

VA handles this differently, and agents who work with Veterans should know both steps.

  1. Tidewater, before the report is final. If it appears the estimated market value will fall below the sales price, the appraiser notifies the requester’s designated Tidewater contact (listed on VA Form 26-1805) and allows two business days to submit additional sales data. For each comp, provide the street address, sales price, date of sale, gross living area and a copy of the listing if applicable. VA describes this as sharing market data only, not an instruction to meet the sales price. The appraiser notes the outcome in the report.
  2. ROV, after the Notice of Value. The Veteran borrower asks VA for reconsideration, not the appraiser. VA reviews the report and the data, and if a change is warranted it issues an amended Notice of Value.

Ask your loan officer on day one who the Tidewater contact is, and keep a short list of strong, recent comps ready. Two business days goes fast.

Realtor checklist when a low appraisal lands

StepWhat to do
1Get the full report from the buyer or lender and read the comps and adjustments.
2Check facts: square footage, bedroom and bath count, lot, recent upgrades, flood or condition notes.
3Pull recent, similar sales near the effective date, with the MLS number for each. Choose your best five or fewer.
4Write a short note for each comp: what it shows and which part of the report it addresses.
5Give the package to the buyer and loan officer; the lender decides whether it meets its ROV process.
6Check contract deadlines, including any appraisal or financing contingency, and ask your broker or attorney what they mean for the deposit.
7If the ROV does not move the value, talk options: price reduction, a bigger down payment from the buyer, or a split.

Keep timing in mind. An ROV and a rate lock both run on calendars, so confirm the lock period with the lender. The buyer’s insurance quote also affects the monthly payment while you renegotiate; see how Florida insurers build a premium. If an inspection turned up condition issues the appraiser could have seen, the inspection period plan helps you line up the paperwork. Listing-side agents can find pricing context in our brokerage’s guide to selling in Central Florida. For the buyer’s own view of this situation, see low appraisal options for buyers.

FAQ

Can I contact the appraiser directly?

On FHA and conventional loans, lender communication with the appraiser must follow appraiser independence rules, so go through the loan officer. On VA, the appraiser is told to send ROV requests from the Veteran, the agent or the lender to VA.

Can the buyer ask for a second ROV?

Not under the FHA, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac borrower-initiated process. Each allows one per appraisal, which is why the first request should be your best package.

Does the buyer pay for an ROV?

On FHA loans, HUD says no ROV costs may be charged to the borrower. Ask the lender about fees on other loan types.

Will a new comp always raise the value?

No. The appraiser must respond in a revised report, but the value can stay the same. Plan for both outcomes.

What if the ROV fails?

The loan is still based on the appraised value, so the choices come back to the contract: renegotiate, bring cash, or cancel under your contract’s terms.

General education, not legal advice. Your lender’s guidelines and your contract govern, and all loans are subject to underwriting.

Have a low appraisal on your desk?

Call me at 407-476-6667 and we can look at the report and the ROV options for your buyer’s loan type. Tariq AbouAdma, Mortgage Loan Officer NMLS 2724176 · Loan Factory NMLS 320841 · Equal Housing Opportunity. Quality Real Estate Finance LLC.

Sources

Site Map